Skip to main content

Best Mad Barn Forage Analysis for New Fall Hay: Test Before You Buy Omneity Premix (2026)

By Samantha Baer··10 min read

The hay is stacked. The loft smells right, the bales are green, and you’re feeling good about the winter. Then you open the feed room and look at the row of supplement buckets you bought last year, against last year’s hay, from a field that had a different spring, a different cutting date, and possibly a different owner. Every forage program rests on a number you probably don’t have yet. Before you reorder anything or add a new bucket, test the hay that’s actually going to feed your horse through spring.

This post contains affiliate links. If you shop through them I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you — and you’ll get my reader benefits. I only feature gear I’d actually put on my own horses or wear for a full day in the saddle.


The Quick Comparison

Product From What it does Best fit
Forage Analysis $59.99 Lab analysis of your hay, pasture, or haylage, plus a diet-balancing report from Mad Barn’s nutritionists Anyone feeding a consistent lot of hay this season
Omneity Premix $54.99 All-in-one vitamin and mineral powder built to cover gaps common in forage-based diets The average horse on decent hay whose results show the usual gaps
AminoTrace+ $64.99 Enhanced vitamin and mineral pellet: elevated copper and zinc, no added iron Easy keepers, metabolic horses (under a vet’s plan), high-iron results

Here’s my order of operations. Buy the test first. Let the results tell you whether Omneity Premix is the right call or whether you belong in AminoTrace+. Don’t buy both of the mineral products. They are not meant to be stacked.


Mad Barn Forage Analysis: The $60 Answer to a Question You’ve Been Guessing At

Mad Barn’s Forage Analysis is the least exciting product in their catalog, and I think it’s the most important one. You send in a sample of hay, pasture, or haylage. It’s analyzed for energy, protein, NSC, and mineral content. Mad Barn’s nutritionists then use those results to put together a diet-balancing report for your horse. Shipping is free, and the report is included.

Why fall is the time to do it. Forage varies with soil, region, species mix, maturity at cutting, weather, and storage. Two loads of “nice second-cut mixed grass” from the same county can look alike and test very differently. If you test now, once the bulk of this season’s hay is in the barn, one result covers months of feeding. If you test in March, you’ve spent the winter guessing.

The order form asks you to describe the forage by type, cutting, and year, for example “2nd Cut Mixed Grasses 2026.” Take that seriously. Label your sample the way you’d label a bloodwork tube, because the report is only as useful as your knowledge of which hay it describes.

The add-ons, and who actually needs them:

  • Wet Chemistry sugar and starch (+$39). This one is worth it for any metabolic horse, meaning easy keepers, horses with an insulin-dysregulation or EMS diagnosis, or a laminitis history. NSC is the number your vet will want to see. Those conditions are veterinary matters. The analysis gives your vet and nutritionist better data. It doesn’t replace their plan.
  • Selenium (+$63). Selenium has a genuinely narrow safe range, and soil levels vary by region. If you’ve wondered whether your horse needs selenium, this add-on plus bloodwork through your vet is how you find out. Don’t guess and don’t go by what the barn down the road feeds.
  • Nitrates (+$17.50). This is a more niche add-on. Ask your nutritionist whether your forage type and growing conditions make it worth running.

Real-use notes:

  • Sample the lot, not a bale. A grab from one flake tells you about one flake. Pull from multiple bales across the same field and cutting, following Mad Barn’s sampling instructions. A careless sample produces a confident-looking report that doesn’t describe your hay.
  • One lot, one test. If you get two different cuttings or two suppliers, those are two hays. Test both, or at least test the one that makes up most of the diet.

Who it doesn’t suit: If you buy hay in small loads from whoever has it every couple of weeks, a single test goes stale with the next delivery. Your money is better spent getting a steadier supply first. Pasture-heavy horses also get less mileage from one test, because grass changes through the season.


Mad Barn Omneity Premix: The Default Pick When the Numbers Look Typical

Once the results come back, most owners with a healthy horse on decent hay land in the same place. Their forage covers calories and most of the protein reasonably well and comes up short on the trace-mineral side. That’s the situation Omneity Premix is designed for.

It’s Mad Barn’s all-in-one vitamin and mineral powder. It contains:

  • 100% organic trace minerals
  • B-vitamins
  • Amino acids
  • Digestive enzymes
  • A live yeast culture
  • Biotin

It is low-NSC, with no added fillers or sugars. I’ll be precise about this: Omneity is formulated to fill gaps common in forage-based diets. Whether it fits your horse’s diet depends on what your hay analysis shows. That’s exactly why the test comes first.

Why I like it as the default:

  • One product instead of four. Without a hay analysis, many owners end up with a zinc bucket, a copper bucket, a biotin bucket, and a vague sense that the horse is “covered.” A single well-formulated premix is easier to get right and much easier to discuss with a nutritionist.
  • The cost is honest. It’s about $1.27 a day. Sizes are 5 kg (41 servings) or 25 kg (208 servings). The 25 kg bag is the better value per serving if your horse is staying on it.
  • Subscribe & Save takes 5% off renewal orders, and you can change, pause, or cancel anytime. That’s useful for a product you feed every day, especially if a new hay analysis next fall changes the plan.

Real-use notes:

  • It’s a powder, so it needs a carrier. A little soaked feed or a dampened handful works for most horses. If your horse sorts powder out of the bucket with surgical precision, Omneity Pellets (from $45.99) are the same idea in pellet form. Per day, the pellets cost more than the powder.
  • Feeding amount comes from the label, your vet, or an equine nutritionist. Your diet-balancing report is the best place to settle it. I won’t give you a number.
  • Transition gradually. That applies to the new supplement and, more importantly, to the new hay. Switching straight from last year’s hay to this year’s is one of the easiest ways to unsettle a hindgut. If gut support is the real question for your horse, I compared Mad Barn’s two main options in Visceral+ vs. Optimum Digestive Health.

Who it doesn’t suit: Horses whose results show high iron, horses with a metabolic diagnosis, and very easy keepers on a tightly controlled diet. Those horses go to the next section. Horses eating enough fortified commercial feed to hit that feed’s recommended intake may already be getting a vitamin and mineral package. Adding a premix on top risks oversupplying some minerals. Have a nutritionist look at the full diet before you add anything.


Ready to try Omneity Premix? Use my link for my reader benefits at Mad Barn → https://madbarn.com?ref=18219


When the Report Points Elsewhere: Mad Barn AminoTrace+

Sometimes the analysis comes back and the typical answer doesn’t fit. The usual reasons:

  • Iron is high relative to copper and zinc.
  • NSC is higher than you’d want for an easy keeper.
  • The horse already lives on a vet-directed metabolic plan.

That is where AminoTrace+ comes in. It’s Mad Barn’s enhanced vitamin and mineral pellet, with elevated copper and zinc, no added iron, and a low-NSC base. Mad Barn positions it for easy keepers, horses on controlled sugar and starch diets, and performance horses with higher demands. It runs from $64.99, about $2.47 a day, so it costs more than Omneity. Pay that difference when the data calls for it, not because “enhanced” sounds better.

The rule I won’t bend: AminoTrace+ and Omneity are both full vitamin and mineral programs. Pick one. Don’t feed both. If your report leaves you torn between them, that’s precisely the question to take to Mad Barn’s nutritionists or your own.

The other rule: Laminitis, EMS, and PPID are veterinary matters. A mineral program can be part of a vet-directed plan. It is never the plan by itself.


How I’d Run This Fall, Start to Finish

  1. Get the year’s hay in and identify your main lot. Know which field and which cutting the horse will eat for the next several months.
  2. Order Forage Analysis and sample it properly. Add sugar and starch for metabolic horses. Add selenium if that question is open, and pair it with bloodwork through your vet.
  3. Hold off on the supplement reorder until the report is back, if you can do that safely. Don’t abruptly stop something your vet put the horse on.
  4. Choose Omneity Premix or AminoTrace+ based on what the numbers and the nutritionist say. Choose powder or pellets based on your horse’s manners at the feed bucket.
  5. Then audit the shelf. Put every leftover single-nutrient bucket up against the report. Some may still have a job. Many won’t, and adding single minerals “just in case” can throw other minerals out of balance.

I’ve talked on the podcast about how much of what we read as a training or soundness issue sits on top of nutrition we never verified. A hay test won’t fix a horse. It will tell you what you’re actually feeding him, and every other decision gets easier once you know that.


Who Should Buy What

  • Forage Analysis: anyone feeding a consistent hay supply this season, especially if you haven’t tested in a year or switched suppliers. This is the first purchase.
  • Omneity Premix: the healthy, average horse on decent hay whose results show the common trace-mineral gaps, with an owner who wants one product doing the job.
  • Omneity Pellets: the same horse, if he’s a powder-sorter or gets very little carrier feed.
  • AminoTrace+: high-iron results, easy keepers, and metabolic horses under a vet’s plan. Never alongside Omneity.
  • Skip the shopping and call the vet if: your horse is losing weight, has hoof soreness, has a sudden coat or condition change, or is behaving differently. Those are diagnostic questions first. Also, if your bigger worry is the gut through a hay transition, start with the Visceral+ buying guide for the gut-stressed horse.

The Bottom Line

New hay means new numbers, and buying supplements before you know those numbers is buying blind. Sixty dollars and a properly pulled sample replace a winter of guesswork with an actual report. In most barns, that report points toward a single, sensible mineral program instead of a shelf of half-used buckets. Test first, then buy what the report shows you need.

Ready to try Mad Barn Forage Analysis? Use my link for my reader benefits at Mad Barn → https://madbarn.com?ref=18219

Reading about it is step one.

Want me in your ear while you actually ride it? Ride Along is my library of audio lessons you play in the saddle — real coaching, every ride.

Explore the Lesson Library →

Or start with two free lessons.

Samantha Baer

About Samantha Baer

Samantha is a professional eventing rider, trainer, and host of The Elevated Equestrian podcast. She believes in training horses with science, empathy, and patience.

Enjoyed this post?

Get new articles delivered to your inbox every week.

No spam, ever. Unsubscribe anytime.